US Sixth Circuit Rules Kalshi Sports-Event Contracts Are Not Federally Regulated "Swaps" and Fall Under State Gambling Laws
CoinDesk reports that on September 25, 2026, the US Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that prediction market Kalshi's sports-event contracts are not "swaps" under federal law, so they fall under state gambling rules rather than federal CFTC oversight. The ruling bears on who regulates prediction markets and deepens a split among appeals courts, which CoinDesk believes should prompt the US Supreme Court to step in.
News date: About 6 min read
Contents
Key terms
- Prediction market: a platform that lets users buy and sell contracts on the outcome of an event (such as an election or a sports game). Kalshi is one such platform.
- Swap: a category of financial contract under US federal law. If a contract is deemed to fall into this category, it is regulated by federal agencies.
- CFTC: the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission, the federal agency that regulates products such as futures and swaps.
- Circuit court of appeals: an appellate court in the US federal court system, organized into regional "circuits," ranking above district courts and below the Supreme Court.
- Circuit split: when different circuit courts of appeals reach different conclusions on the same legal question.
Background: the regulatory tug-of-war between prediction markets and states
CoinDesk reports that prediction markets grew rapidly after the 2024 US election, and since then state governments have sought to bring prediction markets offering sports-related contracts under state regulatory frameworks. The states cite three reasons. First, these platforms compete with state-regulated gambling operators and offer the same products. Second, for many states, federally regulated platforms do not pay state taxes yet still compete with state-regulated operators. Third, prediction markets are often open to people aged 18 and over, while gambling operators in most states accept only customers aged 21 and over.
The Sixth Circuit's reasoning
CoinDesk reports that this ruling covered two lawsuits Kalshi filed separately against regulators in Ohio and Tennessee. Kalshi sought injunctions, that is, court orders barring the states from bringing actions against it. The federal district court in Ohio denied Kalshi's request, while the federal district court in Tennessee granted it. A three-judge panel of the Sixth Circuit agreed that Kalshi had the right to bring these lawsuits, but disagreed that its sports contracts are federally regulated swaps.
Quoting the opinion, CoinDesk reports the court wrote: "While we agree with Kalshi that its sports-event contracts are conditioned on the occurrence of 'event[s],' we conclude that Kalshi’s contracts do not depend on events that are 'associated with a potential financial, economic, or commercial consequence' within the meaning of the statute." In other words, the court accepted that Kalshi's sports-event contracts are conditioned on whether an "event" occurs, but found that these are not events with a potential financial, economic, or commercial consequence as the statute means.
The opinion used the New York Giants winning the Super Bowl as an example of how the wording depends on how an "event" is defined. If the event is "the Giants win," then a win means "the event has occurred." If the event is actually "the game itself," then the Giants winning is merely the game's outcome. The court found that the statutory text does not clearly require excluding "outcomes" from the definition of an event, so it declined to read such a limitation into the statute.
Why this ruling could head to the Supreme Court
CoinDesk reports that before this, the Third Circuit ruled that the CFTC has jurisdiction over prediction markets, while the Eighth Circuit ruled that sports-related contracts are not swaps. The Sixth Circuit's conclusion aligns with the Eighth Circuit, creating a circuit split among appeals courts. CoinDesk believes such a split should prompt the US Supreme Court to take up the matter; the Third Circuit case has already been appealed to the Supreme Court.
| Circuit court of appeals | Swap or not | Regulatory authority | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Third Circuit | Not stated in the report | Found the CFTC has jurisdiction over prediction markets | Case has been appealed to the US Supreme Court |
| Eighth Circuit | Found sports-related contracts are not swaps | Not detailed in the report | Conclusion consistent with the Sixth Circuit |
| Sixth Circuit | Found Kalshi's sports-event contracts are not swaps | Subject to state gambling regulations, not CFTC rules | Addressed two lawsuits in Ohio and Tennessee |
Frequently asked questions
What did the US Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals rule?
CoinDesk reports that on September 25, 2026, the Sixth Circuit ruled that Kalshi's sports-event contracts are not swaps under federal law. The contracts are therefore subject to state gambling regulations rather than the rules of the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).
Why do states want to regulate prediction markets?
CoinDesk reports that states argue prediction markets offering sports contracts compete directly with state-regulated gambling operators and offer the same products. In addition, federally regulated platforms do not pay state taxes, and prediction markets are often open to people aged 18 and over, while gambling operators in most states accept only customers aged 21 and over.
Does this ruling mean Kalshi must stop its services?
CoinDesk's report does not say whether Kalshi will stop offering services in any particular state. The ruling is an appeals court decision, not a final Supreme Court ruling. CoinDesk believes the split among appeals courts should prompt the Supreme Court to step in.
How have other circuit courts of appeals viewed the same question?
CoinDesk reports that the Third Circuit ruled the CFTC has jurisdiction over prediction markets, while the Eighth Circuit ruled sports-related contracts are not swaps. The Sixth Circuit's conclusion aligns with the Eighth Circuit, creating what is known as a circuit split. The Third Circuit case has been appealed to the Supreme Court.
Browse the latest news in this topic
Found this guide helpful? Share it with someone who needs it
Visa, Mastercard and JPMorgan Say Hacked Third-Party Vendors Exposed Customer Data; Ransomware Group n0n Claims Responsibility
Decrypt reports that Visa, Mastercard and JPMorgan say some customer data was exposed after hackers breached third-party vendors. All three say their own networks and payment systems were not breached, and each describes different data.
Blockstream Publishes SHRINCS Post-Quantum Signature Security Analysis: Bitcoin BIP Draft Open for Review, Not Yet Live, Signatures Up to 5,777 Bytes
Chainalysis Opens Limited Preview of Chain, an AI Workspace for Tracing Stolen Crypto: Registration Required
Anthropic Prices IPO at $83 a Share, Raising $81.3 Billion; Trading on Nasdaq as ANT Thursday
Sources
Compiled from the references and verification dates listed above; fares, schedules, product features, and terms can change, so please confirm the latest details on the relevant official website before travelling, booking, or purchasing.