US Judge Acquits Peraire-Bueno Brothers: $25M Ethereum MEV Case Ends With No Retrial

Per Decrypt, Manhattan federal judge Jessica Clarke acquitted the Peraire-Bueno brothers on all charges, including wire fraud, because prosecutors failed to prove a material misrepresentation. The case will not be retried.

News date: About 4 min read

Share on LINE
Contents
  1. 1. What exactly did the court rule?
  2. 2. What happened in the 2023 attack and at trial?
  3. 3. What does the ruling mean for the crypto industry?

Per Decrypt, Jessica Clarke, a federal judge in Manhattan, acquitted MIT-educated brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Monday, ending a criminal case tied to Ethereum MEV (maximal extractable value, the extra profit available from ordering transactions in a particular sequence). This is a court ruling on whether the charges in this case were made out; it does not mean the industry has reached a settled view on this kind of conduct.

What exactly did the court rule?

Decrypt reports that Clarke granted the brothers' motion for acquittal, finding that prosecutors did not prove "material misrepresentation," a necessary element of wire fraud (a US offense involving fraud carried out through electronic communications), and that each of the government's theories failed. She wrote that the question before the court was not whether the brothers' conduct was right or moral, or even whether it violated uncharged crimes.

Decrypt quotes the ruling as describing Ethereum as a "trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use." Clarke also said the scheme "may have frustrated the spirit" of MEV-Boost (software that lets Ethereum validators outsource transaction ordering to specialized block builders), but that this was not enough to amount to fraud. In a footnote she wrote that the prosecution "raises serious due process concerns," though she did not rule on them. The money laundering charge relied on proceeds of the wire fraud and fell along with it.

What happened in the 2023 attack and at trial?

As Decrypt describes it, the case arose from an April 2023 attack on "sandwich bots," automated trading programs that earn MEV by placing orders before and after other people's transactions. According to the ruling, the brothers first placed bait transactions to attract certain bots, then exploited a flaw in relay code (a relay is a program that passes block contents along) to see the bots' bundled transactions before the block was finalized. They then swapped the bait transactions for ones selling the tokens, costing the bots about $25 million in roughly 12 seconds.

Decrypt notes that authorities arrested the two in May 2024, alleging they spent months planning the scheme and trying to conceal the proceeds. At the 2025 trial in Manhattan, an insider testified that the brothers allegedly planned the attack; Clarke declared a mistrial in November 2025 after the jury deadlocked.

Case timeline and charges (source: Decrypt)
AspectDetails (per Decrypt)
Time of attackApril 2023
Size of lossAbout $25 million, in about 12 seconds
ArrestMay 2024
First trialJury deadlock in November 2025, mistrial declared
Final rulingAcquitted Monday, November 16, 2026; no retrial
ChargesWire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud, conspiracy to commit money laundering

What does the ruling mean for the crypto industry?

Decrypt reports that the case drew close attention across the crypto industry; Clarke called it a "first of its kind" prosecution, the same label the government used in its indictment. The ruling shows that, in this case, the court found wire fraud could not be established without a material misrepresentation; the report does not say whether this applies to other cases.

Frequently asked questions

Can prosecutors retry the brothers?

Per Decrypt, the ruling ends the case and there will be no second trial. The report does not mention whether prosecutors will appeal.

Did the judge find the brothers' conduct moral?

The judge made no such finding. Decrypt quotes Clarke as saying the question before the court was not whether the conduct was right or moral, but whether prosecutors proved the elements of fraud.

What is MEV-Boost?

According to Decrypt, it is software that lets Ethereum validators outsource transaction ordering to specialized block builders.

Browse the latest news in this topic

Found this guide helpful? Share it with someone who needs it

Share on LINE

Sources

Compiled from the references and verification dates listed above; fares, schedules, product features, and terms can change, so please confirm the latest details on the relevant official website before travelling, booking, or purchasing.

Lifestyle