Blockstream Publishes SHRINCS Post-Quantum Signature Security Analysis: Bitcoin BIP Draft Open for Review, Not Yet Live, Signatures Up to 5,777 Bytes

Blockstream researchers have published a security analysis of SHRINCS, a post-quantum signature scheme for Bitcoin, and opened a BIP draft for review. The scheme is still being revised; signature size and wallet state management are the main challenges.

News date: About 5 min read

Share on LINE
Contents
  1. 1. What Is SHRINCS, and How Does It Differ from Current Signatures?
  2. 2. What Is the Risk of the Stateful Path?
  3. 3. What Does It Mean for Fees and Block Capacity?
  4. 4. Current Progress and Next Steps

According to Decrypt, Jonas Nick, Director of Research at Blockstream, and researcher Mikhail Kudinov, among others, published a security analysis of SHRINCS on Thursday and opened the BIP draft for public comment. A "post-quantum signature" is a digital signature designed to resist attacks from future quantum computers. A digital signature is the mechanism that proves "this money is really being spent by its holder." A BIP (Bitcoin Improvement Proposal) is a formal proposal for changing Bitcoin. SHRINCS is still at the proposal and review stage and is not an activated Bitcoin feature. If it is adopted in the future, signature size and wallet design could affect transaction capacity and fees.

What Is SHRINCS, and How Does It Differ from Current Signatures?

Decrypt describes SHRINCS as a hash-based signature scheme. The security of such schemes rests on hash functions, which are algorithms that turn data into a fixed-length "fingerprint." SHRINCS uses SHA-256, which Bitcoin already relies on. This is described as a conservative approach that minimizes trust assumptions, meaning it depends on as few unproven building blocks as possible. The scheme combines two spending paths. The first is a smaller, more efficient stateful signature, where the signer must remember which one-time keys have already been used. The second is a larger, costlier stateless path that does not require tracking that state and carries lower implementation risk.

Signature size comparison as cited by Decrypt
ItemDescriptionSignature size (per Decrypt)
ECDSASignature commonly used in Bitcoin todayTypically 71 bytes
Taproot SchnorrAnother signature type used in Bitcoin today (introduced with the Taproot upgrade)64 bytes
SHRINCS statefulSmaller, but one-time keys must be tracked548 to 4,619 bytes
SHRINCS statelessLarger, lower implementation risk5,777 bytes

What Is the Risk of the Stateful Path?

The stateful path relies on one-time keys, each of which can safely sign only one transaction. Decrypt notes that if a one-time state is accidentally reused, an attacker could forge signatures for that address and steal funds. For that reason, wallet developers must track the state of each key carefully. Speaking on MARA Foundation TV, Nick said it must be impossible for users to do anything that leads to this disaster.

What Does It Mean for Fees and Block Capacity?

Some users may prefer stateless signatures out of caution, but Nick warned that widespread adoption could bloat the blockchain and push up network-wide fees. He said it is unclear what the fee market would look like once signatures become so large. He also noted that blocks would fit fewer transactions, meaning fewer people could use Bitcoin. He added that optimization of both paths is accelerating with the help of AI-assisted research.

Current Progress and Next Steps

According to Decrypt, the SHRINCS working group is still revising the specification. Its members include researchers backed by nonprofits such as Brink and OpenSats. Nick and Kudinov have asked for review of the proposal and the security analysis. Kudinov said they need all possible feedback from engineers, cryptographers and protocol developers. Whether SHRINCS is adopted will depend on input from across the Bitcoin ecosystem over the coming months.

Frequently asked questions

Can SHRINCS be used on Bitcoin yet?

Not yet. According to Decrypt, the security analysis has been published and the BIP draft is open for review. The specification is still being revised, and the report mentions no activation timeline.

Why does signature size matter?

Nick says larger signatures mean blocks can hold fewer transactions, which could also affect the fee market.

Do ordinary users need to manage state themselves?

Nick's view is that wallets and the specification should handle this automatically. They should force a fallback to the stateless path whenever the state could possibly be compromised, rather than leaving the burden on users.

Browse the latest news in this topic

Found this guide helpful? Share it with someone who needs it

Share on LINE

Sources

Compiled from the references and verification dates listed above; fares, schedules, product features, and terms can change, so please confirm the latest details on the relevant official website before travelling, booking, or purchasing.

Lifestyle