Lifestyle

Clarity Act Fails Key Senate Vote: Ex-White House Crypto Adviser Witt Says US Crypto Rules Will Now Come More From the SEC and CFTC

Decrypt reports that former White House crypto adviser Patrick Witt says the Clarity Act ran out of time amid an ethics fight, and that US crypto market rules will now depend more on SEC and CFTC rulemaking than on Congress.

News date: About 7 min read

Share on LINE
Contents
  1. 1. What happened to the Clarity Act?
  2. 2. Who will set the rules now? The roles of regulators and Congress
  3. 3. With Congress's balance shifting, what are the limits and uncertainties?

Decrypt reports that Patrick Witt, the former adviser who led the White House push for the Clarity Act, spoke about the bill's failure in the Senate at Solana's Breakpoint conference in London. The Clarity Act was meant to set out a framework for regulating crypto markets, known in the industry as "market structure" rules. This is an ongoing policy story, not a newly settled regulation. In Witt's view, regulators are now more likely to lead on the rules: the SEC (US Securities and Exchange Commission) and the CFTC (US Commodity Futures Trading Commission). Everything below is Decrypt's reporting and Witt's own views.

What happened to the Clarity Act?

According to Decrypt, the Clarity Act failed a key procedural vote in the Senate in September. A procedural vote decides whether a bill can move forward for further debate. Until last month (October), Witt served as executive director of the President's Council of Advisers for Digital Assets and led the White House push for the bill. "We ultimately lost against the clock," he said, adding: "The policy was good. We resolved pretty much all of the policy differences."

Witt blamed the political climate ahead of the midterm elections: "the political issue of ethics really consumed everything else." Decrypt notes that Democrats had raised concerns over the Trump family's crypto ventures. Witt acknowledged that Trump's involvement in crypto was "arguably the issue". He also said the president had agreed to two ethics provisions.

Decrypt describes the second provision as having three parts. First, it would have barred federal officials, including the president, from issuing or sponsoring digital assets. Second, it would have forced the president to divest certain digital assets or put them in a blind trust, which is a trust run by someone else without the owner's involvement. Third, it would have let state attorneys general enforce violations. "There's no precedent for those kinds of things in American law," Witt said.

Who will set the rules now? The roles of regulators and Congress

Witt said the odds of passing a comprehensive replacement bill are low. "I would expect that market structure in the United States is going to be less written on Capitol Hill and more written in the Federal Register, which is where the agencies do their rulemakings and issue their guidance," he said. In other words, agencies would set the rules rather than Congress passing a law. He added that regulators already have "ample authority", and that the administration had to "hold them back a little bit" while the bill played out.

Decrypt says the SEC and CFTC have since moved ahead with their own crypto rules. However, House Financial Services Committee Chairman French Hill has said those efforts fall short of what the legislation would have achieved. Witt said SEC Chair Paul Atkins and CFTC Chair Michael Selig "are committed to moving markets on chain", meaning running markets on blockchains. He framed this as a question of American competitiveness: "Capital is going to go where it's treated best."

Possible paths mentioned in Decrypt's report (based on Witt's and Decrypt's accounts)
PathWitt / Decrypt's accountStatus or limits
Comprehensive Clarity ActWould have set out a framework for regulating crypto marketsFailed a key Senate procedural vote in September; Witt says a comprehensive replacement is unlikely
Folded into larger legislative packagesParts of the bill could still passWitt's view, not confirmed
Targeted powersFor example, giving the CFTC authority over spot crypto markets (where assets are bought and sold for immediate delivery)A possibility Witt raised, not confirmed
SEC/CFTC rulemakingRules and guidance issued through the Federal RegisterDecrypt says both agencies have moved ahead with their own rules; Hill says this falls short of the bill
Democrats' own billA broader market structure bill, per reports cited by DecryptUnconfirmed; the report gives no details

With Congress's balance shifting, what are the limits and uncertainties?

Decrypt reports that Democrats won control of both chambers of Congress in the November 2026 midterms. Witt said he is "not bearish on the industry overall" because the regulators and the president remain in place. He also said opposition to crypto is increasingly generational rather than purely partisan. In his view, some Democrats, such as Sen. Elizabeth Warren, are "going to be 100% opposed to anything that seemingly is favorable to crypto". He said younger lawmakers on both sides, such as Sens. Angela Alsobrooks and Ruben Gallego, see crypto as "part of the fabric of financial infrastructure".

Witt noted that the GENIUS stablecoin bill also lost an initial procedural vote in 2025. A stablecoin is a crypto token designed to hold a steady value. That bill recovered because it came early in Trump's term. With Clarity, he said, "we knew that we were going to get one shot at it, and unfortunately we just came up short." Citing The Hill, Decrypt says Witt left the administration in October. He said he has held talks with crypto firms, venture capital firms and defense companies, and hopes to announce his next move in the coming weeks.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Clarity Act completely dead now?

Decrypt reports that the bill failed a key Senate procedural vote in September, and Witt thinks a comprehensive replacement is unlikely. He also said parts of the bill could still pass inside larger legislative packages. So the report does not say its contents will never return.

What practical impact does this have on ordinary users?

According to Witt, market rules will increasingly come from the SEC and CFTC through rulemaking and guidance, rather than from a single act of Congress. The report does not describe specific effects on individual users. It is worth watching for later announcements from these two agencies.

What are the ethics provisions Witt mentioned?

Decrypt describes the second of the two provisions. It would have barred federal officials (including the president) from issuing or sponsoring digital assets, forced the president to divest certain digital assets or put them in a blind trust, and let state attorneys general enforce violations. Witt said Trump had agreed to two ethics provisions.

Will Democratic control of Congress bring a new bill?

Decrypt says Democrats are reportedly planning to push their own, broader market structure bill. The report gives no details, timeline or likelihood of passage.

Browse the latest news in this topic

Found this guide helpful? Share it with someone who needs it

Share on LINE

Sources

Compiled from the references and verification dates listed above; fares, schedules, product features, and terms can change, so please confirm the latest details on the relevant official website before travelling, booking, or purchasing.

Lifestyle