Lifestyle

Elvis and Eminem Rights Holders Sue Suno, Adding Two More Cases to the AI Music Imitation Dispute

According to The Verge, rights holders of Elvis Presley's music and the publisher of Eminem's records have each sued AI music company Suno, alleging it generates music and lyrics imitating these artists. Suno already faces suits from Sony, UMG and others; the company says it has safeguards in place.

News date: About 4 min read

Share on LINE
Contents
  1. 1. What happened: two new lawsuits
  2. 2. What the complaints say
  3. 3. Suno's response
  4. 4. Key points

What happened: two new lawsuits

According to The Verge, AI music company Suno faces two more lawsuits. The plaintiffs include a group of rights holders to Elvis Presley's music (the parties who own rights related to his music) and the publisher of some of Eminem's best-known records. They allege Suno unlawfully generates music and lyrics that imitate these artists.

The Verge notes that the lawyers in the Presley case argue Suno violates Tennessee's ELVIS Act. The law's full name is the Ensuring Likeness Voice and Image Security Act, and it makes it illegal for AI companies to replicate a singer's voice. The report does not say what legal basis the Eminem publisher's case relies on.

What the complaints say

The Verge quotes the Presley rights holders' complaint as saying: "Suno has mechanically encoded itself with artists' identities, hard-work, creativity, and time, and harnessed them all for a consistent conveyor belt of cold hard cash." In essence: Suno mechanically built artists' identities, effort, creativity and time into its system and turned them all into a steady stream of cash.

The Verge also quotes the complaint as saying: "Suno's ravenous race to the bottom aims to make human creativity obsolete, coldly replicating without a license in seconds what takes years to learn, struggle with, maintain, and endlessly attempt to make better and perfect." In essence: Suno aims to make human creativity obsolete, replicating without a license, in seconds, what takes people years to learn and hone.

According to The Verge, these suits closely resemble one filed in September by Jason Isbell and others. That case alleged Suno made imitations of the plaintiffs but did not directly claim copyright infringement.

Suno's response

Suno spokesperson Cat McCormack told The Verge that Suno's purpose is to help people create new, original music rather than to exploit anyone's name or likeness, and that the company prohibits unauthorized use of artists' work.

McCormack said Suno does not allow specific artist names and songs as prompts (the text instructions users give an AI to describe what they want generated). The company also works with third-party vendors to screen user-uploaded audio files and lyrics for possible misuse. She added that Suno will keep strengthening its safeguards, adding new protections for artists and users.

Key points

Compiled from The Verge's report
ItemWhat The Verge reports
PlaintiffsRights holders of Elvis Presley's music; publisher of some of Eminem's well-known records
AllegationUnlawfully generating music and lyrics that imitate the artists
Legal basisPresley case: Tennessee's ELVIS Act; Eminem case: not stated in the report
Suno's responseDoes not allow artist names and songs as prompts; uses third parties to screen uploaded audio and lyrics
Other lawsuitsSony, UMG, Isbell, Reservoir Media and others

Frequently asked questions

Who sued Suno this time?

According to The Verge, the plaintiffs are a group of rights holders to Elvis Presley's music and the publisher of some of Eminem's best-known records.

What legal basis do the Presley rights holders cite?

According to The Verge, their lawyers argue Suno violates Tennessee's ELVIS Act, which makes it illegal for AI companies to replicate a singer's voice. The report does not state the legal basis for the Eminem publisher's case.

How did Suno respond?

According to The Verge, spokesperson Cat McCormack said Suno does not allow specific artist names and songs as prompts, works with third-party vendors to screen uploaded audio and lyrics, and will keep strengthening its safeguards.

How do these suits relate to the Isbell case?

According to The Verge, they closely resemble the suit Jason Isbell and others filed in September, which alleged Suno made imitations of the plaintiffs but did not directly claim copyright infringement.

Browse the latest news in this topic

Found this guide helpful? Share it with someone who needs it

Share on LINE

Sources

Compiled from the references and verification dates listed above; fares, schedules, product features, and terms can change, so please confirm the latest details on the relevant official website before travelling, booking, or purchasing.

Lifestyle