Lifestyle

TWCA Website Certificates Fall Short of International Standard: MODA Urges 962 Government Agencies to Renew 9,772 Certificates by Nov. 6 to Avoid Browser Security Warnings

Taiwan's Ministry of Digital Affairs says some TLS certificates issued by TWCA have serial numbers with only 24 bits of actual randomness, below the 64-bit minimum required by international standards. The case involves 962 government agencies. New certificates have been reissued; sites that do not renew by Nov. 6 may show security warnings.

News date: About 4 min read

Share on LINE
Contents
  1. 1. What Happened
  2. 2. Scope of Impact and Progress
  3. 3. Practical Impact on the Public
  4. 4. Follow-up Testing and Accountability

What Happened

According to a press release from the Ministry of Digital Affairs, the international community Bugzilla reported on Oct. 30 that the serial number entropy of some certificates issued by Taiwan Certificate Authority (TWCA) did not meet international standards. Serial number entropy is how much truly random data a certificate's serial number contains. The standard requires serial numbers to contain at least 64 bits of cryptographically secure random data.

MODA explained that although TWCA designed its certificate serial numbers to be 128 bits long, only the first 12 bits and last 12 bits were actually random, with the middle filled with fixed values, so the actual randomness was only 24 bits.

MODA said that after receiving the report on Oct. 30, it immediately required the provider to produce compliant new certificates within two days. MODA also launched cross-agency notifications to speed up certificate replacement and avoid disrupting normal website browsing.

Scope of Impact and Progress

MODA explained that TLS (Transport Layer Security) certificates are used to establish secure communications. TWCA's website TLS certificates are provided to private-sector sites, and also to government agencies through procurement by MODA. According to MODA's inventory, this incident involves 962 government agencies and 9,772 website certificates.

Compiled from the MODA press release
ItemMODA's statement
Date reportedOct. 30, reported via Bugzilla
ProblemSerial numbers have only 24 bits of actual randomness, below the required 64 bits or more
Scope962 government agencies, 9,772 website certificates
New certificatesTWCA finished reissuing them on Nov. 1
Renewal progressAs of the evening of Nov. 2, 926 certificates had been renewed
Renewal deadline urged by MODABy Nov. 6

According to MODA, TWCA is using a proactive reissuance mechanism in which its system emails the new certificate files directly to the staff member at the original applicant agency. MODA has also activated its chief information officer contact channel, asking each agency's chief information officer to help urge and start the certificate renewal process. MODA said it will keep tracking progress.

Practical Impact on the Public

MODA said that if the relevant websites do not complete certificate renewal by Nov. 6, visitors may see security warning messages when browsing. MODA also stated that no concrete information security harm has been caused so far, and urged agencies and other TWCA certificate users to complete renewal as soon as possible, before Nov. 6.

Follow-up Testing and Accountability

MODA said it has commissioned an independent third-party professional organization to conduct in-depth testing of TWCA, comprehensively reviewing its certificate issuance and management mechanisms, and will require TWCA to make improvements based on the results. MODA will also investigate breaches of contract and impose fines and seek compensation as the contract provides.

Frequently asked questions

What exactly is wrong with the certificates?

According to MODA, the serial numbers of some TWCA certificates are designed as 128 bits, but the actual randomness is only 24 bits, below the international standard of at least 64 bits.

What do members of the public need to do?

MODA's appeal is directed at agencies and other TWCA certificate users, asking them to complete renewal by Nov. 6. MODA notes that visitors to sites that have not been renewed may see security warnings.

Has any information security harm occurred?

MODA says no concrete information security harm has been caused so far.

How will TWCA be dealt with?

MODA says it has commissioned an independent third party to conduct in-depth testing and will require TWCA to improve based on the results. MODA will also investigate breaches of contract and impose fines and seek compensation as the contract provides.

Browse the latest news in this topic

Found this guide helpful? Share it with someone who needs it

Share on LINE

Sources

Compiled from the references and verification dates listed above; fares, schedules, product features, and terms can change, so please confirm the latest details on the relevant official website before travelling, booking, or purchasing.

Lifestyle